Why are climber's swami belts and firefighters pompier belts not safe for rope rescue?

The response indicates that climber's swami belts and firefighters' pompier belts are considered unsafe for rope rescue primarily because they restrict the ability to breathe if a fall occurs. This is a critical concern in rescue scenarios. When a climber falls while using a narrow belt, the sudden drop can cause the belt to exert excessive pressure on the abdomen and chest, which can impede normal breathing.

Proper harnesses used in rope rescue are designed to distribute the weight more effectively and provide comfort and safety during both dynamic movements and suspended positions. They are crafted to allow full range of motion and do not compromise respiratory capacity when a person is suspended. In contrast, the narrow construction of swami and pompier belts fails to provide this essential feature, making them unsuitable for situations where prolonged suspension and safety in breathing must be maintained.

Other options, while they may have elements of truth, do not address the primary vital concern of safety in the event of a fall. Correct equipment is paramount in ensuring not just the rescue but also the safety and well-being of the individual in distress.